Changes in tuberculosis burden and its associated risk factors in Guizhou Province of China during 2006–2020: an observational study

Background Understanding the trends of tuberculosis (TB) burden and its risk factors at the provincial level in the context of global End TB targets is crucial to identify the progress and challenges in TB control. We aimed to estimate the burden of TB and risk factors for death from 2006 to 2020 for the first time in Guizhou Province, China. Methods Data were collected from the national TB surveillance system. Four indicators of TB burden and their corresponding age-standardized rates (ASRs), including incidence (ASIR), prevalence (ASPR), mortality (ASMR) and disability-adjusted life years (DALYs) (ASDR), were estimated and stratified by year, age, gender and prefecture. Temporal trends of ASRs were presented by locally weighted regression, and the annual percentage change was calculated. The correlation between gross domestic product (GDP) per capita and ASRs was evaluated by Pearson correlation analysis. The associated risk factors for death in PTB patients were determined using logistic regression models. Results A total of 557,476 pulmonary TB (PTB) cases and 11,234 deaths were reported, including 2233 (19.9%) TB specific deaths and 9001 (80.1%) deaths from other causes. The 15-year average incidence, prevalence and mortality rates were 94.6, 102.6 and 2.1 per 100,000 population, respectively. The average DALY rate was 0.60 per 1000 population. The ASIR and ASPR have shown downward trends since 2012, with the largest percentage decrease in 2020 (ASIR: -29.8%; ASPR: -30.5%). The number in TB specific deaths consistently decreased during the study period (P<0.001), while the increase in deaths from other causes drove the overall upward trend in ASMR and ASDR. Four ASRs remained high in males and 5 prefectures. GDP per capita was negatively associated with the ASIR, ASPR and ASDR (P<0.05). Among PTB patients, men, patients with no fixed job, those with a low GDP level, patients with increasing age, those previously treated, those with severe symptoms, those transferred in and those receiving directly observed treatment were more likely to suffer death. Conclusion Guizhou has made progress in reducing PTB cases and TB specific deaths over the last 15 years. Targeted interventions are needed to address these risk factors for death in PTB patients and high-risk areas.


Background
Tuberculosis (TB) is an infectious disease caused by the bacillus Mycobacterium tuberculosis [1].The sites typically affected by the disease are the lungs (pulmonary TB, PTB), but there are also other affected sites (extrapulmonary TB) [1].TB was the leading cause of death as a single infectious agent worldwide before the pandemic of coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) [1].The End TB Strategy remains a priority for the World Health Organization (WHO) [2].In recent years, encouraging progress in reducing TB burden has been made globally.However, the COVID-19 pandemic has reversed these gains [1].Redoubling efforts and investments are therefore essential to mitigate the TB burden worldwide.
Estimating the trends of the TB burden is fundamental to guide effective control strategies for each country.China is one of the highest burden countries for TB in the world [2].To fight this disease, China implemented three national plans for TB prevention and control between 2001 and 2020, covering three periods: period I (2001-2010) [3], period II (2011-2015) [4] and period III (2016-2020) [5].During the three periods, China has been working to expand the directly observed treatment short-course strategy (DOTS) to the entire country [3,6], strengthen the national surveillance systems to capture all PTB cases [7], improve the TB health-care system [4][5][6], and protect patients from the financial burden of TB treatment [5,6].Under the guidance of these national policies, China has made remarkable progress in TB control, but it is still far from achieving the End TB targets [5,6].Thus, understanding China's TB status is urgently needed, especially at the provincial level.Knowledge of which province lags behind in controlling TB can inform effective intervention efforts that aim to promote progress in achieving the End TB targets at the national level.
Guizhou is a province in southwestern China with a low economic level and the third highest TB incidence [8].There are 9 prefectures and 88 counties with a population of 38.56 million [9].In keeping with the national pace, Guizhou also implemented three provincial TB plans in three corresponding periods [8,10,11].In 2005, a national TB Information Management System (TBIMS) was established based on the internet to monitor realtime and detailed information on PTB nationwide [7].The platform has been fully implemented in Guizhou since 2006 to collect information on PTB patients.The available data from the TBIMS platform can be used to track the PTB burden.However, no study to date has assessed the changes in the TB burden in this province using data from this platform.An assessment of TB burden trends is crucial to identify the progress and challenges in TB control.Tracking the risk factors associated with disease burden can help develop effective control measures to appropriately address these issues.
Based on the GBD methodology and literature review above, this observational study analyzed at the population level, aims to provide a comprehensive assessment of the PTB burden and risk factors for death in Guizhou to advance evidence-informed prevention plans.We collected data from the TBIMS database over a 15-year period from 2006 to 2020 and analyzed the PTB burden with the incidence, prevalence, mortality and DALYs.They were stratified by gender, age, prefecture and annual gross domestic product (GDP) per capita.The risk factors associated with all-cause death and TB specific death were further estimated.

Data sources
The data of all notified PTB cases and the population between January 2006 and December 2020 in Guizhou were collected from the TBIMS database.Approval for use of the database was granted by the Department of Tuberculosis Prevention and Control of Guizhou Center for Disease Prevention and Control.The study included a total of 557,476 patients who were diagnosed and registered during the study period.The remaining 348 patients were excluded either their time of diagnosis or registration was outside the study period, and data on their treatment outcomes were missing.The patients' data extracted from the database were age, gender, ethnic group, occupation, home address, date of diagnosis, date of registration, registered residence at the time of TB diagnosis, anti-TB drug history, classification of patients, severity of disease, types of case finding, directly observed treatment (DOT) status throughout the entire treatment and treatment outcomes (all-cause death and TB specific death).Data on annual GDP per capita were obtained from the yearbook of Guizhou Provincial Bureau of Statistics [9].Fundamental geographic data were downloaded from the National Geomatics Center of China to make the prefecture-level ring map of Guizhou.

Definition of PTB cases and types of case findings
PTB is defined as bacteriologically confirmed or clinically diagnosed TB with lesions in the lungs [7,26], including patients with both pulmonary and extrapulmonary TB [7].Based on a history of previous TB treatment, PTB patient cases are classified as new patients and previously treated patients.The former is defined as a patient who has never received anti-TB treatment or taken anti-TB drugs for less than 1 month.The latter is defined as a patient who has been treated for TB in the past for at least 1 month [26].
Types of case finding are classified as passive case finding (PCF), active case finding (ACF) and transfer in [34,35].PCF refers to the way in which individuals present to health facilities for TB diagnosis after they have developed suspicious symptoms of TB and are aware of their symptoms [35].ACF is defined as a systematic screening and clinical evaluation of people at high risk of developing TB for early detection of patients.It includes a variety of approaches, such as contact screening of TB patients at home or in the community [35].Transfer refers to patients who were originally registered in other health facilities for TB care but transferred to the current health facilities to continue care [36].

Statistical analysis Descriptive analysis for general characteristics
Descriptive analysis was presented to understand the distribution of demographic characteristics of PTB cases in 3 periods (2006-2010, 2011-2015, 2016-2020).Frequencies and percentages were used for categorical variables, while medians and interquartile ranges (IQRs) were used for continuous variables.A ring map made by ArcGIS (version 10.4,ESRI Inc., Redlands, CA, USA) [37] was used to display the spatial-temporal patterns of PTB burden from 2006 to 2020 yearly at the prefecture level.Other statistical analyses in this study were performed by R (version 4.2.1, Vienna, Austria).

PTB burden analysis
According to the methodology of GBD online [12,15,19,38], the number, rates and age-standardized rates (ASRs) of PTB incidence, prevalence, mortality, and DALYs were calculated and stratified by gender, age, geographic location and GDP per capita over time.Incident PTB cases were new patients, while prevalent PTB cases were all existing patients, including previously treated patients and new patients.Deceased PTB cases were recorded as patients who died for any reason during the study period.The rates and ASRs of incidence, prevalence, and mortality were expressed as the number of cases per 100,000 population [15,19].DALYs were presented in thousands [24].
ASR was calculated based on a global standard age structure [39], and its specific approaches have been described in detail elsewhere [20,25].The 95% uncertainty interval (UI) was assessed for corresponding rates (incidence, prevalence, mortality, and DALYs) and ASRs (age-standardized incidence rate, ASIR; age-standardized prevalence rate, ASPR; age-standardized mortality rate, ASMR; and age-standardized DALY rate, ASDR).The annual percentage change was calculated to show the changes in ASRs from 2006 to 2020 (percentage change = [(final value -starting value)/|starting value|] × 100).
The estimated annual percentage change (EAPC) was used to evaluate the temporal changes in ASRs over these 15 years.It was calculated as EAPC=100×[exp(β)−1]. β was obtained from a linear regression model: Y =α+βX +ε, where Y equals ln (ASR), X is the calendar year, and ε is the error term [20,25].The 95% confidence interval (CI) of the EAPC could also be obtained from the linear model [20].When the EAPC and its 95% CI are positive, the ASR presents an upward trend; if both the EAPC and 95% CI are negative, the ASR is considered a downward trend; otherwise, the ASR is stable.Temporal trends of ASRs were smoothly presented by locally weighted regression (Loess) [40,41].

The correlation between GDP per capita and PTB burden
Pearson correlation analysis was used to evaluate the correlation between GDP per capita and PTB burden (ASIR, ASPR, ASMR and ASDR) in 3 periods.Linear correlation diagrams with correlation coefficients (ɣ) and P values were used to present those results.The nine prefectures were ranked in descending order of average GDP per capita for each period.

Risk factors associated with all-cause death and TB specific death
Variables associated with all-cause death and TB specific death were explored initially by separate univariate analysis, and variables with a P value less than 0.2 were included in the separate multivariate logistic regression modeling process.The likelihood ratio test was assessed at each step and used to determine the final model where only variables with a P value ˂0.05 remained.The odds ratio (OR) and 95% CI were calculated for each predictive variable.A total of 10 variables were included in the analysis, including time periods, average GDP per capita over 15 years, gender, age, ethnic group, occupational status, classification of patients, severe symptoms status, types of case finding and DOT status.

Ethical review
In this study, data were collected from routine TB surveillance system.The approval of the study were obtained from Guizhou Medical University, and the Department of Tuberculosis Prevention and Control of Guizhou Center for Disease Prevention and Control.

Demographic characteristics of PTB patients
The demographic characteristics of all patients and their three subgroups are shown in Table 1.A total of 557 476 PTB cases were reported in Guizhou from 2006 to 2020.Three subgroups included the cases registered in 3 periods: subgroup 1 (from 2006 to 2010, n=167421), subgroup 2 (from 2011 to 2015, n=203013) and subgroup 3 (from 2016 to 2020, n=187042).Of all cases, 66.4% were male and 33.6% were female, with a 2.0 sex ratio.The median age was 42.0 (IQR 26.0~59.0)years.A total of 70.5% of cases were Han, and the cases were mainly farmers (77.8%), followed by migrant workers and unemployed individuals (11.2%).A total of 92.2% of patients were new cases, and 7.8% had previously received anti-TB therapy.Moreover, 48.3% of patients were found by PCF followed by transfer (33.0%).A total of 50.9% of patients received DOT during the whole treatment.In terms of the distribution of patients in 3 periods, the proportion of women, ethnic groups, patients aged 60 years and above, new patients and patients found by ACF gradually increased over time.However, the proportions of patients who received DOT and those found by PCF showed a downward trend.

Mortality of PTB
The number of all-cause deaths in PTB patients was 11 234 in Guizhou over 15 years, with an average mortality rate of 2.1 (95% UI: 1.7~2.4)per 100 000 population (Table 2).The number of deaths, annual mortality rate and ASMR had pronounced increasing trends during the past 15 years (Table 2, Fig. 1C).Men had a higher ASMR each year than women (Fig. 1C).The mortality rate of PTB was not detected in all age groups but increased with age and was particularly high in the elderly for both sexes (Fig. 2C).With regard to geographic distribution, the ASMR of PTB remained high in Bijie and Qiannan (Fig. 3C).In 2020, a pronounced increasing trend in ASMR was observed in Anshun (Fig. 3C).

DALYs of PTB
The number of DALYs due to PTB was 286 137, with an average DALY rate of 0.60 (95% UI: 0.54~0.66)per 1000 population over the past 15 years in Guizhou (Table 2).
The number and rate of DALYs and ASDRs increased during 2006 and 2018 and then decreased slightly after 2019 (Table 2, Fig. 1D).The annual ASDR in males was higher than that in females (Fig. 1D).In both sexes, the DALY rates were unevenly distributed among the age groups.Most cases occurred in elderly individuals, with a peak in those aged 70-79 years (Fig. 2D).In terms of geographic distribution, higher ASDRs were observed in Qiannan and Bijie (Fig. 3D).

Correlation between GDP per capita and PTB burden
According to the level of GDP per capita, 9 prefectures were ranked from highest to lowest: Guiyang (N.1, highest), Liupanshui (N.2), Zunyi (N.3), Qianxinan (N.4), Qiannan (N.5), Anshun (N.6), Tongren (N.7), Qiandongnan (N.8), and Bijie (N.9, lowest).In each period, the GDP per capita of Guiyang was always the highest, while that of Bijie remained the lowest.Figure 4 shows the relationship between GDP per capita and PTB burden for the 9 prefectures in 3 periods.There was a significant negative association between the average GDP per capita and ASIR (2011~2015: ɣ=-0.87,P=0.005; 2016~2020:   ɣ=-0.88,P=0.003), ASPR (2011~2015: ɣ=-0.90,P=0.002; 2016~2020: ɣ=-0.88,P=0.003) and ASDR (2016~2020: ɣ=-0.72,P=0.037).ASMR was not found to have a significant negative correlation with GDP per capita in each period.Thus, further exploration is needed to determine the association between deaths in PTB patients and average GDP per capita over 15 years.5 presents the results from the final separate multivariate logistic regression model.As shown in Table 5, both indicators are found to increase the risk for all-cause death but decrease the risk for TB specific death if the patient is registered in 2 periods (2011~2015 and 2016~2020) or if the patient is in an older age group.Those with a low GDP level were more likely to experience all-cause death but less likely to experience TB specific death.Patients with the following 3 characteristics were more likely to suffer all-cause death and TB specific death: previously treated, no fixed job and receiving DOT during entire treatment.In addition, patients who were male, had severe symptoms or were transferred in were more likely to suffer all-cause death.However, patients who were ethnic minority or found by PCF were more likely to experience TB specific death.

Discussion
This study collected a large sample size of 557 476 PTB cases and 11 234 deaths from the TBIMS database over 15 years (2006-2020) in Guizhou Province.This is the first comprehensive assessment of the PTB burden and risk factors for all-cause death and TB specific death in this province to advance evidence-informed prevention plans.Our main finding shows that there was a downward trend in TB specific deaths and the incidence and prevalence of PTB.However, all-cause mortality and DALYs had an upward trend in the past 15 years driven by deaths from other causes.The highest PTB burden was observed among males, people aged 60 and above, and in 5 prefectures with relatively low economic levels.
Patients with no fixed job, those previously treated and those receiving DOT were more likely to suffer all-cause death and TB specific death.Patients registered from 2011 to 2020 and those with older age increased the risk for all-cause death but decreased the risk for TB specific death.Those with a low GDP level were more likely to experience all-cause death but less likely to experience TB specific death.Patients who were male, had severe symptoms or were transferred were more likely to suffer all-cause death.However, patients who were ethnic minority or found by PCF were more likely to experience TB specific death.
Our study shows that the highest PTB caseloads were among young to middle-aged adults, and more than nine out of ten were new PTB cases.These results concur with previous studies conducted in China [7,42].The proportion of new patients, female patients, minority patients and elderly patients has increased over time, which was probably due to the good performance of the ACF strategy implemented in China since 2011 [4,5].ACF plays an important role in TB case finding, especially in students [43], elderly individuals [44] and contacts [35].However, only half of the patients in our study underwent DOT throughout the duration of treatment, and this proportion fell to less than 50% between 2016 and 2020.DOT is the core component of DOTS [45].The proportion of all PTB patients administered DOT is one of the key indicators for assessing the level of TB care and prevention [36].Inadequate implementation of DOT leads to poor treatment adherence and further generates the emergence of TB drug resistance [45].Thus, our findings suggest that incentives and supervision mechanisms should be established to encourage DOT providers to manage cases effectively and to assess their performance regularly.
In this study, temporal trends of ASRs show that the highest PTB burden was observed in 2008.This may be due to the adequate case detection and notifications after full coverage of DOTS and TBIMS during the period from 2006 to 2010 [46].Since 2012, both the overall ASIR and ASPR of PTB showed a downward trend in Guizhou, which was consistent with the trends of PTB nationwide [47].Meanwhile, the number in TB specific deaths consistently decreased during the study period in Guizhou.These decreases reflect the effectiveness of TB control measures in recent decades.A sharp decline was observed in the ASIR and ASPR in 2020.One of the possible reasons may be attributed to the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on TB services [1].Globally, the number of TB patients newly diagnosed and reported had a large drop in 2020 compared with 2019 due to COVID-19 [1].Another possible reason might be explained by some effectiveness of wearing face masks in the community to prevent respiratory disease infection risk [48].However, more reasons are worth further exploration to guide appropriate policy decisions during high-risk periods.Additionally, it is important to highlight that PTB mortality and DALYs had an upward trend in the past 15 years in Guizhou, primarily due to the continuous increase in deaths from other causes over the same period.Death from other causes in PTB patients might be caused by adverse drug effects [49] and common comorbidities, such as TB-DM (diabetes mellitus) [50], TB-HIV positivity [51] and other age-associated comorbidities [49].Therefore, our findings suggest that reducing the TB disease burden in Guizhou will require a multipronged approach, including health system strengthening, integration of TB and common comorbidity services, and person-centered approaches to support treatment.Consistent with previous studies [18,42], a gender disparity in PTB burden was observed in our study, with males being more affected in all age groups.This can be explained by smoking [16,42], more frequent exposure to TB bacillus in work activities, and lower levels of selfcare and health-care use for TB in this gender [16,19].Adult males comprise the main labor resources.Loss of their jobs or reduced productivity due to TB could generate a negative socioeconomic impact for them, their family and society [16].Furthermore, our study found that the PTB burden increased with age and mainly fell on people aged 60 and above.The elderly population faces many challenges that make them more susceptible to PTB infection and unfavorable treatment outcomes [42].The challenges include decreased lung function, low tolerance to anti-TB drugs and increased comorbidity [49].These results suggest that more attention should be given to males and elderly people.The expansion of financial and social protection could improve TB prevention and increase favorable TB treatment outcomes among vulnerable populations [16].
Regional variations in the PTB burden were observed in this study, and they were mainly concentrated in 5 prefectures (Bijie, Anshun, Tongren, Qiandongnan and Qiannan) with low economic levels in Guizhou.Our findings show a clear negative association between the PTB burden and GDP per capita of a prefecture, which corroborates previous findings [1,52].The following reasons might explain this phenomenon.First, areas with lower economic development have insufficient spending on financial and social protection, public health expenditure and hospital funding for TB.Second, areas with underdeveloped economies have weaker health systems and a lack of adequate health services and trained human resources.Third, people living in economically underdeveloped areas have relatively weak educational levels and health-care awareness.They will use less income for health care and will not see a doctor unless there is a major illness.TB is fundamentally a disease of poverty [53].Thus, the WHO End TB Strategy highlights the importance of socioeconomic determinants for TB prevention and treatment [52][53][54].Both economic development and increasing social protection spending can reduce the TB burden [52].
In terms of risk factors associated with deaths in PTB patients, first, our study shows that patients with no fixed job, those previously treated and those receiving DOT were more likely to suffer all-cause death and TB specific death.Similar results have been reported in other studies.Low income [29] and illiterate schooling [32], previous TB treatment [30,31,51]and the use of DOT during the entire treatment [55] were independently associated with death in TB patients.A possible explanation for the correlation between DOT and death was that DOT was utilized by providers according to decreased social support or increased severity of illness [55].However, additional studies are needed to evaluate the quality of DOT implementation in the treatment of TB patients in Guizhou.Second, our findings show that patients registered from 2011 to 2020, those with older age and those with severe symptoms were more likely to experience all-cause death but less likely to experience TB specific death.In our study, of the all-cause deaths, 19.9% were TB specific deaths, and 80.1% were deaths from other causes.The number in TB specific deaths decreased from 2011 to 2020, reflecting the considerable success of Guizhou's anti-TB program.Local governments and political organizations have taken action to control TB through improved TB health care systems and financial initiatives [8,11].However, the upward trend in deaths from other causes means that TB control in Guizhou still faces many challenges, such as the emergence of drug resistance, more individuals with TB-DM and other age-related comorbidities.Third, this study found that patients who were male or those who were transferred in were more likely to suffer all-cause death.These results correspond with the findings from other studies.Male TB patients with low treatment adherence, smoking, alcohol or drug use are associated with high death [32,56].The process of patient referral leads to a delay in diagnosis and treatment, which increases mortality rates among PTB patients [30,57].Finally, patients who were ethnic minority or found by PCF were more likely to experience TB specific death.These factors may be explained by ethnic groups with TB living away from health facilities; PCF delays their seeking TB care and leads to unsuccessful treatment outcomes [35,58].Thus, ACF is beneficial for vulnerable people to overcome barriers to accessing health services [35,58].Therefore, our findings suggest that targeted interventions are needed to address these risk factors to reduce deaths among TB patients in Guizhou.
This study has several limitations.First, only PTB patients based on the TBIMS database were included in this study.As PTB accounts for more than 90% of TB patients in China [7], our results could represent the overall epidemic of TB in Guizhou.Second, underreporting of TB cases and missing data were inevitable when using notification data collected from the existing surveillance system [7,59,60].In our study, after 348 patients are excluded, the remaining 557,476 cases are still representative of the TB status for this province.Third, the data from the surveillance system only contain limited variables.Some risk factors for the TB burden in the GBD were not available in the TBIMS database, such as smoking [7,[15][16][17], alcohol use [7,[15][16][17], diabetes [15,16] and sociodemographic index (SDI) [15].Thus, their effects on PTB burden could not be assessed in this study.Meanwhile, we could also not assess those potential variables associated with deaths among TB patients, such as "bacterial number" and drug-resistant status of patients, treatment regimen, comorbidities and complications.Finally, our analysis of the relationship between GDP per capita and PTB burden (ASIR, ASPR, ASMR and ASDR) cannot be interpreted as causal, as it reflects only the average historical correlation between GDP per capita and each of the measures [15,19,20].Despite these limitations, the results of this study should be useful for policy decisions and spur future studies to resolve the limitations and obtain more precise results.

Fig. 1 Fig. 2
Fig. 1 Trends in numbers and age-standardized rates of PTB burden in Guizhou Province, 2006-2020.A Trends of PTB incidence from 2006 to 2020.B Trends of PTB prevalence from 2006 to 2020.C Trends of PTB all-cause mortality from 2006 to 2020.D Trends of PTB DALYs from 2006 to 2020.Notes: PTB: pulmonary tuberculosis; DALYs: disability-adjusted life years

Fig. 3
Fig. 3 The ring map for spatial-temporal distribution of PTB burden in Guizhou Province, 2006-2020.A Spatial-temporal distribution of annual and average ASIR of PTB.B Spatial-temporal distribution of annual and average ASPR of PTB.C Spatial-temporal distribution of annual and average ASMR of PTB.D Spatial-temporal distribution of annual and average ASDR of PTB.Notes: PTB: pulmonary tuberculosis; ASIR: age-standardized incidence rate; ASPR: age-standardized prevalence rate; ASMR: age-standardized mortality rate; ASDR: age-standardized DALYs rate; DALYs: disability-adjusted life years

Fig. 4
Fig. 4 The correlation between GDP per capita and PTB burden in Guizhou Province, 2006-2020.A The correlation between average GDP per capita and ASIR of PTB in 3 periods.B The correlation between average GDP per capita and ASPR of PTB in 3 periods.C The correlation between average GDP per capita and ASMR of PTB in 3 periods.D The correlation between average GDP per capita and ASDR of PTB in 3 periods.Notes: PTB: pulmonary tuberculosis; GDP: gross domestic product; ASIR: age-standardized incidence rate; ASPR: age-standardized prevalence rate; ASMR: age-standardized mortality rate; ASDR: age-standardized DALYs rate; DALYs: disability-adjusted life years

Table 1
Characteristics of PTB cases in Guizhou Province from 2006 to 2020 PTB Pulmonary tuberculosis, IQR Interquartile ranges, PCF Passive case finding, ACF Active case finding, DOT Directly observed treatment

Table 2
Numbers, rates, age-standardized rates and percentage changes for PTB incidence, prevalence, mortality and DALYs from 2006 to 2020 in Guizhou PTB Pulmonary tuberculosis, DALYs Disability-adjusted life years, ASIR Age-standardized incidence rate, ASPR Age-standardized prevalence rate, ASMR Age-standardized mortality rate, ASDR Age-standardized DALYs rate, UI Uncertainty interval

Table 3
EAPCs of age-standardized rates for PTB incidence, prevalence, mortality and DALYs in three periods in Guizhou EAPCs Estimated annual percentage changes, PTB Pulmonary tuberculosis, DALYs Disability-adjusted life years, ASIR Age-standardized incidence rate, ASPR Age-standardized prevalence rate, ASMR Age-standardized mortality rate, ASDR Age-standardized DALYs rate, CI Confidence intervals

Table 4
arate univariate analysis for risk factors associated with all-cause death and TB specific death.Variables with P values less than 0.2 after univariate analysis were included in the initial multivariate logistic regression modeling process.Table

Table 4
Univariate analysis for risk factors associated with all-cause death and TB specific death in Guizhou, 2006-2020 TB Tuberculosis; GDP Gross domestic product, PCF Passive case finding, ACF Active case finding, DOT Directly observed treatment

Table 5
Multivariate logistic regression analysis for risk factors associated with all-cause death and TB specific death in Guizhou, 2006-2020 TB Tuberculosis, Adj.Adjusted, OR Odds ratio, CI Confidence intervals, IR-test Likelihood ratio test, GDP Gross domestic product, PCF Passive case finding, ACF Active case finding, DOT Directly observed treatment